Top 10 Dick Rating OnlyFans Accounts 2025 - Specialists for Honest Reviews

By Dominic Ashford - Published on April 8, 2025 - Updated on April 30, 2025

Ever wondered what someone really thinks about your dick? These Top Dick Rating OnlyFans Accounts will give it to you straight - in the form of praise, playful roasting, or something in between. We tested 80 creators (mostly from the US, Spain, Mexico and UK) and narrowed it down to the 10 who stand out for their honesty, creativity, and all-around vibe.

These aren’t generic, one-word replies. The Best Dick Raters on OnlyFans know how to make it personal. Some offer thoughtful breakdowns with personality. Others go full savage or lean into domination. Whether you’re into audio messages, custom videos, or real-time reactions, these creators bring their own twist to the experience - and yes, they actually pay attention.

So, if you’re new to this world or just looking to upgrade your next rating, these are the Dick Rating Creators we’d recommend starting with. Scroll down, get curious… and maybe get humbled.

Want to find your favorite Dick Rater, but don't know what to look for? Read this article: How to find the best OnlyFans accounts. This guide will help you find your perfect creator.

Best
Dick Rating
OnlyFans!
Dick Rating OnlyFans 1 Dick Rating OnlyFans 2

What is Dick Rating?

If you're new to dick rating, it’s pretty much what it sounds like: sending a photo (or video) of your penis to a creator and getting a personalized review in return. Sometimes it’s quick and cheeky. Other times it’s a full breakdown of size, shape, grooming, angles, vibe, and more.

On OnlyFans, dick ratings have become their own genre. For some fans, it’s about validation. For others, it’s rooted in kink (humiliation and submission, for example). And for a lot of people, it’s just plain curiosity. What would she say? Would she purr out a compliment while stroking your ego - or laugh as she tears you apart? Would her voice go soft... or strict? Would it turn you on or leave you squirming?

Performers and influencers offer all kinds of rating styles: some stick to straightforward text, others add voice notes, video reactions, or even live commentary. You can keep it anonymous or go all in - it’s really up to your comfort level.

Bottom line: a Dick Rating Creator isn’t just reacting to a pic. They’re offering an experience. And like any good experience, the best ones feel personal, real, and maybe just a little addictive.

What Makes a good Dick Rating Profile?

With so many Dick Rating Creators on OnlyFans, what actually makes a profile worth checking out? Here’s what we looked for when narrowing down the Best Dick Rating profiles on HotRanked:

They actually look - and react
The best creators don’t just slap a number on it. They give real feedback; maybe a comment on your grooming, size, or angle. A good rating feels like they took a moment to pay attention, not just copy-paste a generic line.

You get what you paid for (and on time)
Top performers are consistent. They deliver ratings quickly, respond to DMs, and don’t ghost you after the tip comes through. If someone’s offering custom content or live reactions, they show up and follow through.

They have a clear tone or style
Some are flirty and fun. Others go full domme, savage, or sarcastic. The best profiles make their tone clear so fans know what to expect - whether you want praise, humiliation, or a bit of both.

They go beyond text
Ratings that include voice notes, custom videos, or even live reactions feel way more personal. It’s one thing to read a review, another to hear it spoken out loud.

These creators turn a simple concept into something way more fun - and way more memorable.

How a Dick Rating Works?

Here’s how it usually goes: you send a photo (or video) of your dick through a pay-per-view message or custom request, and the creator sends back a rating. Some keep it short and snappy. Others go in with detailed feedback, voice notes, or even a reaction video.

Most Dick Rating Creators keep things private, and plenty offer anonymous options. You can also let them know what kind of tone you’re after - funny, sweet, savage, humiliating - it’s your call.

When HotRanked reviewed 80 profiles for this list, we looked for creators who actually engage with fans, reply on time, and make the interaction feel real. A good rating isn’t just about the number; it’s about how the creator responds, reacts, and keeps it personal.

HotRanked’s Top Dick Rating OnlyFans Accounts

After reviewing 80 different Dick Rating Creators, we narrowed it down to the 10 that actually delivered. These influencers and performers stood out for their consistency, creativity, and the way they connect with fans - not just through ratings, but through custom content, DMs, and all-around personality.

After flirty feedback, savage roasts, or something totally unique? These are the Best Dick Rating profiles on OnlyFans right now. Some are low-key pros, others are full-on influencers - but all of them know exactly what they’re doing.

Top 10 Dick Rating OnlyFans

  1. Emma Magnolia

    @emmamagnoliaxo Los Angeles, California

    Emma Magnolia is a famous Dick Rating OnlyFans model and the top performer offering this type of service. How popular is she? Well, this creator has 2.929.902 Likes – the most in this ranking! Her Twitter (X) page boasts another 1M followers and is packed with lots of fun and candid short clips and pics of her round, juicy backside.

    Besides Dick Ratings, Emma Magnolia also enjoys sexting and direct messages, as well as producing B/G, G/G, threesomes scenes and lots of fetish-friendly content. We highly recommend checking out her Pornhub account and the ASMR videos on YouTube. She has a nerdy side, too, with a love for gardening, cooking, traveling and reading comic books. Send Emma Magnolia a picture of your penis on OnlyFans and be surprised by her feedback!

    emmamagnoliaxo OnlyFans

    USD

    12.00
    Top Features
    • Custom Feedback On Dick Pics
    • Premium Adult Videos
    • Fetish Content
    • VIP Subscription Packages
    • ASMR Videos
  2. Haley

    @hazey_haley United States

    Of course, we couldn't forget the beautiful and talented Haley, the leading YouTube OnlyFans influencers with personalized Penis Ratings. In fact, she has more than 1.2M followers on YouTube, where she creates funny and flirty comedy videos that are actually quite original. Her Instagram boasts a whopping 1.5M followers, packed with fun glimpses and insights into her daily life and behind-the-scenes moments.
     
    Join her OF page for just 10,00$ and get access to daily uploads that include shower content, toy play, feet fetish, threesomes, creampies, JOIs, couple scenes, lesbian shoots, 1-on-1 chats and top dick ratings on the platform! Her biggest passion is penises. She loves pictures and recordings of men's best parts! Check out the free account: @haleysfreepage.

    Tip: Discover more best Instagram OnlyFans.

    hazey_haley OnlyFans

    USD

    10.00
    Top Features
    • Exclusive 1-on-1 Dick Review
    • Threesome Experiences
    • Toy Play Sessions
    • Foot Fetish Content
  3. Vanessa Bohorquez

    @vanebp19 Mexico City, Ciudad de México

    Let's show some love for the beautiful Latina Vanessa Bohorquez, a high-ranked OnlyFans profile that specializes in Dick Ratings. This busty, curvy, big-booty Mexican model has a body that was made for nude posing and explicit adult content. Visit her IG page and prepare to have your mind blown! Simply put, there's a reason why she boasts over 2.6M followers on Instagram. She has a natural talent for cosplaying (Tip: more OnlyFans Cosplayers), gym videos and posing seductively for the camera, and she's also a talented porn star.

    Vanessa Bohorquez offers 2.103 videos on her account, which is more than any other creator on the list. The membership includes daily updates, anal play, live shows, female ejaculation, direct messaging, creampies, BBC, sexting, custom shoots and (obviously) cock ratings. She has a preference for thick and long cocks, no matter if they’re white or black!

    vanebp19 OnlyFans

    USD

    7.99
    Top Features
    • Interactive Live Shows
    • G/G and B/G Content
    • BBC Experiences
  4. Brontë B

    @bbrontte United Kingdom

    Next up on our list is Brontë B, an incredibly popular British OnlyFans performer with a private dick rating service. This breathtaking, dark-haired beauty has big fake tits, tattoos, piercings and a thin waist. Brontë B loves to travel, especially to exotic beaches. Visit her Instagram and enjoy a wide selection of sexy bikini photos! She also has a passion for luxury cars and loves striking sexy poses alongside them.

    As for her OnlyFans profile, it's by far one of the best on the platform. The subscription is priced at just 10,00$ and gives you access to explicit daily content, JOI, stripteases, voice notices, live streams, toy play, 1-on-1 messages and the hottest cock reviews available.

    bbrontte OnlyFans

    USD

    10.00
    Top Features
    • Custom Genital Reviews
    • Seductive Office Sessions
    • Private One-on-One Chats
    • Fetish Friendly
  5. Bri Blossom

    @briblossomvip United States

    The next top cock rater in our countdown is Bri Blossom. She's a cute, soft-spoken, fetish-friendly blonde American MILF who'd love to offer her opinion on your manhood. Sign up and get access to regular video diaries about her everyday life, sexy karaoke, daily nude content, solo and couple scenes, sexting services and dick reviews.

    If you want to get rated by a top US OnlyFans model, Bri Blossom is an excellent choice. She takes time for all penis evaluations. Full of passion and attention to detail, she gives you personal feedback! This gorgeous, mature babe knows how to keep things interesting – just take a peek at her Instagram for pro-shot photos and glimpses into her private life. With nearly a million Likes, thousands of pictures and hundreds of clips, Bri Blossom is definitely a keeper.

    briblossomvip OnlyFans

    USD

    14.99
    Top Features
    • Intimate Rating Sessions
    • Hot Karaoke Videos
    • Private Behind-the-Scenes
    • Exclusive Deals on Memberships
  6. Carla Boom

    @carlaboom Barcelona

    Do you want to have your package rated by a stunning MILF from Spain with massive boobs and an angel face? That's exactly what you get by subscribing to Carla Boom, a top-tier Dick Rating OnlyFans performer with green eyes, long blonde hair, tattoos, piercings, 37.665 posts and 27.948 pics. If that's not enough, she's also appeared in XXX films on different sites, including Brazzers, Bang Bros, Reality Kings and Mofos.

    Want to get a taste of what you'll get with your membership to this free account? Visit her Twitter profile (where she has 45K followers) and check out some of her shocking, highly daring model photos. While you're there, visit her VIP OF site: @carlaboomvip.

    HotRanked also recommends the list of Top MILF OnlyFans.

    carlaboom OnlyFans

    USD

    Free
    Top Features
    • Premium JOI Videos
    • POV Performances
    • Dom/Sub Content
    • Huge Collection Of Sexy Content
  7. Isabella

    @izzygreen Jacksonville, Florida

    Few models on here are as cute and bubbly as Isabella, a trending dick ratings OnlyFans creator from the state of Florida. This hot college girl loves giving fans exactly what they want: authentic interaction! That's why she's totally obsessed with providing services like unlimited chatting, live shows, 1-on-1 messages, JOIs, sex tapes and the most interactive cock reviews on the platform.

    Isabella can be found streaming on Twitch and creating ASMR videos for her YouTube channel. Her Twitter (X) account is filled to the brim with erotic pics and some jaw-dropping selfies, mostly shot in her skimpy underwear.

    izzygreen OnlyFans

    USD

    15.00
    Top Features
    • Honest & Detailed Feedback
    • Bikini Collection Try-On
    • Live Shows
  8. Sarah Jessie

    @sarahjessie Las Vegas, Nevada

    Sarah Jessie (also known as Angela Marie Clardy) is a popular mature OnlyFans performer and adult star who's known for sharing impressive dick-rating videos. This blonde beauty has appeared in more than 500 professional videos, working with such companies as Evil Angel, Brazzers, Reality Kings, Porn Pros and Penthouse.

    Born and raised in Detroit, Michigan, to hippie parents, Sarah spent time living in both Germany and Australia. While in Australia, she studied Business and dipped her toes into the erotic world as a stripper. She eventually moved to California, where she kicked off her porn career in 2007, just before turning 30.

    She's not just a content creator and X-rated star – she's also a director and producer who creates raw content for fans who like things real. Her Free OnlyFans page is packed with roleplay sessions, plus customs, panty drops, and spicy size rating vids that fans can't get enough of.

    sarahjessie OnlyFans

    USD

    Free
    Top Features
    • Roleplay Lover
    • Exclusive Size Rating
    • Elegant Nude Shots
  9. Pati

    @patryciakayy Miami, Florida

    Next on the ranking is Pati, a popular performer offering exclusive Dick Rating reviews. Why exclusive? Because she is incredibly detail-oriented and time plays no role in the evaluation! No other influencer looks at your penis as closely as she does! This Miami-based influencer has long blonde hair, body art and large, natural D-cup breasts. Her main specialty is swinger content and group play adventures with several partners at the same time. Nevertheless, she's also great for custom shoots, solo sessions and intimate couple scenes.

    Alongside her adult content, Pati is a pro golfer, Miami realtor, and swinger who knows how to have fun. Want to get her something nice? Click on her Amazon Wish List to buy her a box of fancy golf balls and maybe even a sexy tennis dress. Did we mention Pati has more than 1.5M followers on Instagram?

    Tip: Browse this list for more top OnlyFans from the United States.

    patryciakayy OnlyFans

    USD

    Free
    Top Features
    • Swinger Adventures
    • Special Custom Content
  10. Lea

    @leavixx London, England

    No top-ranked Dick Rating countdown would feel complete without the lovely Lea. She's a talented UK content creator, vegan, writer and independent escort. Heck, she even makes house calls as a professional domina! Her YouTube channel is packed with entertaining travel vlogs to locations around the world, and she's also available on Pornhub.

    Lea is as real as it gets – 100% natural with no filters or cosmetic surgery, just pure authenticity that fans absolutely love. Subscribe to her OnlyFans account for just 11,99$ and receive hundreds of uncensored, full-length videos that feature everything from solo masturbation to oral, domination and more. You also get FREE dick ratings, direct chats and exclusive customs.

    leavixx OnlyFans

    USD

    11.99
    Top Features
    • Solo Play Videos
    • Uncensored Photo Sets
    • Free Dick Ratings

Quick Comparison: Top 3 Dick Rating OnlyFans Creators

Want a quick overview of the top performers? Here’s a summary of the three best Dick Rating OnlyFans models based on popularity, interaction style, and overall fan experience. Use this table to easily compare their strengths and find the perfect creator for your next custom review.

UsernameLikesInteraction LevelPrice for Rating
@emmamagnoliaxo 2,9M Very High $12,00
@hazey_haley 951,6K Very High $10,00
@vanebp19 1,2M High $10,00

Ready to get rated? Pick your favorite and slide into their DMs today!

Dick rating context & culture

Dick ratings might sound niche at first, but they’re one of the most requested custom services on OnlyFans - and the reasons why people seek them out are more varied than you might expect.

For some, the appeal is rooted in submission - being judged, teased, or humiliated. Others are chasing approval, attention, or just a laugh. One guy might want a confident Influencer to tell him he’s working with a 10. Another might beg for a savage 3 and a verbal takedown. That’s the thing about dick ratings - they’re personal, and they tap into something different for everyone.

Security & anonymity
Most Dick Rating Creators offer fully private and anonymous options. You don’t have to show your face, and many allow you to message without using your real name. Some creators even use coded menu terms if you’re shy about asking directly. The whole setup is designed to be low-pressure and discreet - especially if you’re just testing the waters.

For more information on security, read this article: Staying Anonymous and Safe on OnlyFans.

Pricing
Prices vary, but most performers offer ratings as pay-per-view (PPV) messages. You’ll typically see:

  • Basic text ratings: $5-$15
  • Audio or voice note ratings: $10-$25
  • Custom video reactions: $20-$50+
  • Bundles or combos with subscriptions

Some creators even include one rating per month in their paid subscription. Others offer “add-ons” like SPH (small penis humiliation), CEI (cum eating instructions), or dirty talk in the same clip.

Tip: Want to know how to save money on OnlyFans? This guide will tell you.

Free vs paid profiles
Free OnlyFans pages sometimes offer basic ratings via tips or PPV requests, but they’re often limited. If you’re looking for fast replies, more effort, or audio/video content, paid pages usually bring more to the table. Subscriptions also tend to unlock better access to DMs and exclusive perks like custom bundles or priority requests.

Tip: read this guide for the differences between free and paid OnlyFans accounts.

Reasons for the ratings
Some users are curious. Others want a confidence boost - or a reality check. Many are into the kinkier side of things. For fans into SPH, humiliation, or exhibitionism, having someone rate your penis can be part of a much larger experience.

Some crave the sting of a brutally honest 3/10. Others get off on being told they’re a “perfect 9” by a confident Influencer who knows how to play into their fantasy. For many, it’s not about the score - it’s about being seen, judged, teased, or praised. That emotional edge is what turns a basic review into something way more intimate.

Fetish overlaps and roleplay
Dick ratings often overlap with other kinks. Some performers combine them with domination, cuckold roleplay, or CEI. A few even offer duo ratings - imagine being judged by a couple or two dominant women at once. Others work your photo into a full-blown scenario: roleplay via chat, custom sexting, or a guided JOI (jerk-off instruction) with your rating built in.

Real talk? The creativity out there is wild. Some fans send photos weekly as part of a longer-term humiliation dynamic. Others request a side-by-side comparison to “see how they measure up.” The best Dick Rating profiles don’t just send a number; they roast you, flirt with you, hype you up, or drag you down in the most entertaining - and enticing - way possible.

In other words, a great Dick Rating doesn’t feel like a transaction. It feels like they’re in on the game with you, be it you’re chasing praise, punishment, or a little of both.

Related categories for Dick Rating

Similiar categories

Ready to get rated?

Whether you’re in it for the praise, the roast, or just pure curiosity, these Top Dick Rating OnlyFans Accounts are the best of the best. We’ve tested 80 creators and picked the ones who actually deliver - no lazy replies, no fake engagement, just real reactions from people who get the kink.

Check out our full list of Dick Rating Creators, explore different styles, and find the performer who matches your vibe. Trust us - there’s someone out there who’ll rate you exactly how you’ve always wanted.

Some creators also offer reviews for free. This guide, How to Get Free OnlyFans, provides information about the options and ways to get free OF influencers.

Back to the
Dick Rating
creator list!

Frequently Asked Questions

We rank OnlyFans models based on engagement (likes, posts), subscriber growth, content quality, social media influence and overall popularity.
Yes! We continuously track the performance of OnlyFans content creators and update our rankings to reflect the latest trends. New influencers are added as they gain popularity.
Yes - dick ratings are totally allowed on OnlyFans. They fall under custom content and messaging features, just like voice notes, sexting, or video reactions. As long as both parties are consenting and it doesn’t break community guidelines, creators are free to offer them.
The top specialists include @emmamagnoliaxo, @hazey_haley, and @vanebp19 . Subscribe to them for honest reviews and feedback on your cock.
It depends on the creator, but most Dick Rating Creators respond within 24 to 72 hours. Some are quicker, especially if you're a subscriber or tipping extra. Want it fast? Check their bio or menu—they’ll usually tell you what to expect.
It can be either - or both. Some fans want praise, others crave humiliation, and plenty just enjoy the weird thrill of it all. The best dick rating profiles let you choose the tone: sweet, savage, playful, or completely ruthless. You set the tone, and they’ll run with it.
There is no fixed price for Cock Ratings and the price will vary depending on the model, level of detail and whether it's a video or text review. They typically range from about $5 to $50 per rating. There are also influencers who offer dick reviews for free! Try the best free OnlyFans now.